Panaro’s, a Buffalo N.Y. restaurant that gets more than red sauce right

cannoli at panaros restaurant buffalo ny
Even the cannoli was done right, filled with sweetened ricotta only after ordering.

Braciole is a special-occasion dish in Italian-American households, the sort of dinner centerpiece you might see on a birthday or anniversary. That’s partly because of the amount of kitchen labor it requires.

Recipes usually call for pounding out beef round or a similar cut, and using it to roll up savory fillings, including seasoned bread crumbs and cheeses, prosciutto maybe, and even hard-boiled eggs. Then the little packets are tied up, seared in a hot pan and braised in tomato sauce.

It’s one of the dishes I’ve only had in restaurants. I never understood what the fuss was about until I ate at Panaro’s (571 Delaware Ave., 716-884-1033).

braciole panaros restaurant buffalo ny

At this small Italian homestyle lunch specialist near Allen Street, the outer wrapper is pork, and the fillings include ground beef and an egg. It adds up to a savory, rich bundle to take apart on a bed of pasta served with simple, fresh-tasting tomato sauce.

It’s available Wednesdays only, and at $9.50, it’s the most expensive dish on the regular menu. But I’d say it’s worth it.

How satisfying was it? That afternoon, if I happened to be lined up against a wall to wait for a firing squad, I would have declined the cigarette. “I’ve finally had good braciole. Just give me the blindfold.”

I shouldn’t have been surprised. The stuffed peppers that arrived as an appetizer had already distinguished themselves with stuffing that avoided the spackle syndrome afflicting most versions on Buffalo menus.

stuffed peppers panaros restaurant buffalo ny

Here the filling was clearly bread crumbs, cheese and herbs. I tried to remember if I’d ever had a stuffed pepper with a relatively light payload before, and couldn’t think of one.

cappicolla pizza panaros restaurant buffalo ny

Across the table, Kevin Purdy’s “Panaro pizza” was a lovely jumble of grilled cappicolla, roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella. The crust was a tasty shade of brown, thinner than the usual Buffalo swamp. Its quality reminded me that Panaro’s is a bakery that happens to serve lunch, with an array of cakes-to-order and traditional Italian cookies available on the side.

After the place had gotten so many things right, I let down my guard enough to order a cannoli. After waiting in the cannoli line at the Modern Bakery in Boston’s North End, I’ve avoided specimens that are not filled to order. There’s a lot of moisture in the ricotta filling, and the delicate shells lost their crunch in a jiffy.

At Panaro’s, the server said, they fill cannolis after you order them. There were chocolate chips in the filling, but I couldn’t complain too much. I’d finally had my braciole.

bracioles panaros restaurant buffalo ny

About these ads


Filed under beef, food, meat, pork, restaurants

4 responses to “Panaro’s, a Buffalo N.Y. restaurant that gets more than red sauce right

  1. Julie

    Looks delicious….on a sort of related note, I was wondering if anyone had ever been to DiTondo’s. I heard about it briefly, and was told it was good, but I don’t know anyone that has been there.

  2. Julie, Julie, Julie.

    Put “DiTondo’s” in the search box and you find this:

    I eat there once a month. Excellent simple pastas and sandwiches, and one of Buffalo’s better burgers. Skip the stuffed peppers.

    Also notable for its high ratio of faces you’ve seen somewhere. Judges, cops, legislators, contractors, politicians, Sabres executives.

  3. Julie

    Yay! Thanks for the info! I read this blog religiously, and the post was from early 2007, so cut me some slack :)
    The high ratio of faces you recognize reminds me of Chef’s…last week I saw Phil Rumore and “Baby” Joe Mesi eating together.

  4. Mary

    Panaro’s is one of the best lunch places around….I eat there on a regular basis, and have never been disappointed. If you get a chance, try the chicken in the grass…it’s amazing how moist & juicy the chicken cutlets are…they are pounded thin, breaded and sauteed….then topped with spinach & mozzarella cheese. Absolutely addicting!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s